Conspiracy Theory (1997) – Richard Donner

Man, I miss Dick Donner. He was always incredibly reliable as a director and delivered a number of my favourite films. He also always seems to get a fun performance out of Mel Gibson.

Long before he was publicly problematic, Gibson was everywhere, in front of and behind the camera. With Conspiracy Theory he once again put himself in Donner’s hands (they worked together six times).

This time out, Gibson plays taxi driver Jerry Fletcher. Jerry has never met a conspiracy he didn’t like or couldn’t talk about, and he seems to have an unhealthy fascination with a member of the Department of Justice, Alice Sutton (Julia Roberts).

His monthly ‘zine has hit on something, and now people are turning up dead. But which conspiracy is the right one. Whichever one it is, it seems to be headed by the villainous Dr. Jonas (Patrick Stewart), who will stop at nothing to keep a lid on things, and seems to have a vested interest in Jerry.

Gibson has this way of delivering his dialogue that makes almost all of it sound improvised. He is also able to walk the line between making Jerry likable and more than a little troubling.

Having (kind of) convinced Alice that he’s on to something, the pair find themselves pursued by the government’s entire alphabet, and they are completely unsure of who to trust and if there’s a way out.

With a score by Carter Burwell, the film rolls along, has a couple of impressive set pieces and lets Stewart be truly menacing.

Roberts makes a fairly solid pairing with Gibson; I think she looks fantastic here, though she hasn’t always been my favourite actor. And speaking of favourite actors, I love that Steve Kahan shows up in this – I mean, of course he does; he was Donner’s cousin, and has been in all of his films.

It doesn’t have the playfulness that the Lethal Weapon sequels and Maverick had. It’s darker, but Gibson and Donner end up with a watchable and enjoyable thriller that encourages your sense of paranoia.

This era, the Donner era of Gibson, is what I miss most; he was just so enjoyable to watch onscreen. To be clear, that is acting-wise; I realize there was lots of trouble happening off-camera for him.

I’ve never met a Dick Donner film I don’t like on some level, and this one is no different. I hadn’t seen this one in decades, so it was fun to explore this one again.

Leave a Reply